Cookies on the SIM Sherpa website

We use cookies to track which pages on our website readers visit most. This helps us understand which topics people find interesting, to write more articles about them.

You can accept these tracking cookies or choose to block them. You can change these settings at any time.

X close

✖ Tracking cookies deleted and blocked

Ok, we will not track your page views as you move around any part of the SIM Sherpa website. But we will use that one cookie to remember you don't want to be tracked.

Click here to unblock tracking cookies

X close

✔ Cookies accepted

Thank you for accepting cookies for the SIM Sherpa website. This will help us constantly improve our content.

If you ever want to change your cookie settings for our website, go to our Cookies page here.

Basic Pay As You Go SIMs: networks with cheapest rates

SIM card and top up symbol

The retailers featured on this page may compensate us when our readers follow links to their websites and make a purchase. More

Here are the networks with the cheapest traditional pay as you go SIMs, where you just top up with credit and pay for what you use. Last updated: 8th June 2023.

In our pay as you go SIM guide

Only a few networks offer traditional Pay As You Go now

Pay as you go SIM packs

Monthly PAYG bundles are more common

In this guide we’ll go over the mobile networks that offer the best traditional Pay As You Go schemes. These networks let you top up with credit and pay for what you use out of that.

Only a few networks still let you pay as you go this way. Instead, most networks now prefer to offer monthly bundles of mins, texts and data, which are usually sold at a higher price than their pay monthly SIM plans.

If you usually top up with £5 credit each month anyway, then you might want to consider these options despite being pay monthly plans:

In this guide we’ve gone over every network that offer a traditional Pay As You Go scheme and ranked them on their costs per min, text and MB of data, and if they let you hold onto your credit for the maximum time.

How each network compares

1st: 1pMobile have by far the cheapest PAYG in the UK

1p Mobile tariff banner

Cheap and cheerful rates on 1pMobileSee all rates

at 1pmobile.com
(opens in a new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Cheap and easy to understand tariff
Green plus sign 5G/4G/3G/2G coverage via EE’s network
Green plus sign Over the phone customer service

What we don't like:
Red minus sign Minimum £10 top up every 4 months

1pMobile offer the cheapest pay as you go rates you’ll find in the UK. True to their name you’ll pay 1p per minute, text and MB of data rates, making the other networks’ rates seem expensive:

They use EE’s network to provide signal, so you’ll get 3G/4G/5G in the same areas on 1p as you would on EE (check coverage here). And 1p include network features like WiFi calling too (read our full review here).

1p offer WiFi calling and 4G calling. It’s essentially the same network experience as being on EE directly, meaning you’re not getting an inferior product despite paying less.

The only downside is that you have to top up with at least £10 credit every four months, or else your SIM will be deactivated and your credit will disappear. But if you keep topping up, your credit won’t expire.

Useful link: All other costs and charges on 1pMobile

Joint 1st: Talk Home Mobile have cheap rates on EE

Talk Home pay as you go tariff

1p per min, text and MB of dataSee full rates

at talkhome.co.uk
(opens in a new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Uses EE’s 5G/4G/3G/2G network
Green plus sign Cheap 1p tariffs

What we don't like:
Red minus sign 90 day top-up requirement
Red minus sign No WiFi/4G calling
Red minus sign No over-the-phone customer service

Talk Home Mobile are another smaller provider on EE’s network that offer super cheap 1p per min, text and MB of data tariffs. You’ll also get 5G where available if you’re on a 5G-ready device.

After taking out a SIM with them you can top up with credit and Pay As You Go right away. They have the same 1p per minute, text and MB of data rates as 1pMobile, making them a brilliant choice for PAYG:

The main downside is that you’ll have to make a chargeable action (such as sending a text) and top up some credit every 90 days to keep your SIM active. Otherwise your SIM will be suspended and you’ll have to top up to reactivate it.

But you can top up with as little as £2.50 rather than £10 like on 1pMobile. Talk Home don’t have WiFi/4G calling though, and their customer service is a bit worse than 1p. But they’re the best alternative to joining 1pMobile on PAYG.

Useful link: Talk Home’s guide to their PAYG scheme

3rd: ASDA have the cheapest PAYG on Vodafone’s network

ASDA PAYG SIM

The second cheapest UK PAYG ratesOrder free SIM card

at mobile.asda.com
(opens in a new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Signal via Vodafone’s 4G/3G/2G network
Green plus sign No minimum top up requirement
Green plus sign A long time to use up your credit

What we don't like:
Red minus sign Still much higher rates than 1pMobile
Red minus sign Tariffs have gone up in price

ASDA Mobile recently upped their PAYG rates, leaving 1pMobile as by far the cheaper option. But when you compare ASDA to the networks below, their rates don’t seem too bad. And there’s no top up requirement like on 1pMobile:

You’ll only lose your credit if you don’t use your SIM at all for 180 days in a row. If you do nothing for 270 days straight, then your account will be deactivated (see their guide here).

ASDA are a decent alternative to 1pMobile if you’d prefer to be on Vodafone’s network rather than EE’s and if you’d rather not have to top up every 3 months. However, 1p are the best option if you want the cheapest rates.

Useful link: ASDA Mobile FAQs

4th: Tesco provide the cheapest PAYG rates on O2’s network

Tesco Mobile triple credit tariffs explained

Order “No Contract” for Triple CreditOrder a free SIM

at tescomobile.com
(opens in new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Excellent coverage via O2’s network
Green plus sign Get through your credit at your own pace
Green plus sign Your credit is tripled

What we don't like:
Red minus sign Tariffs are fairly high

There are only two providers on O2’s network that let you Pay As You Go in the conventional way. Tesco are one of them and giffgaff are the other. The two actually have exactly the same UK tariffs:

But Tesco’s scheme is a little bit complicated as you can either top up with £10, £15 or £20 to get a triple credit boost. For example, topping up with £10 will actually get you £30 of credit.

That effectively means that their PAYG rates can work out to a third of what’s shown above, which is cheap. But the bonus credit (like the extra £20 in our example) disappears if you don’t use it up within a month.

Your regular credit won’t expire as long as you do something that costs money at least every 180 days, like make a token call to someone. For us though, the Triple Credit tariff is too complicated to bother with.

Useful link: Tesco Mobile’s pay as you go rates

5th: giffgaff’s PAYG rates can get expensive quickly

Free credit offer banner

£5 free credit on your first £10 top upUse free credit offer

at giffgaff.com
(opens in a new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Call other giffgaff users for free
Green plus sign Coverage via O2’s 5G/4G/3G/2G network
Green plus sign They deliver SIMs outside the UK

What we don't like:
Red minus sign Tariffs are higher than networks above

giffgaff largely focus themselves around selling monthly bundles of minutes, texts and data that they call “goodybags”. But they do still offer traditional pay as you go for more infrequent phone users:

Those rates are alright if you don’t use your phone often and just need a SIM for “emergencies”. But if you frequently use your phone your usage will add up fast.

Handily, calls to other giffgaff users can actually be free so long as you top up every three months (otherwise you get charged at their standard rate), which can save a bit of credit.

And your credit lasts forever as long as you use your SIM at least once every six months. The downside is that their rates will add up fast compared to the networks above, hence why they’re this low down.

Useful link: Check your coverage on giffgaff

6th: Lebara’s rates will also add up quickly

Screenshot of Lebara's pay as you go rates

Their out of plan tariffsSee all costs

at mobile.lebara.com
(opens in new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Uses Vodafone’s 5G/4G/3G/2G network
Green plus sign Get 5GB free for transferring your number to them

What we don't like:
Red minus sign Rates are quite high
Red minus sign Have to use some credit every 90 days

Lebara are the second provider on this list who use Vodafone’s network. But their tariffs are quite high, meaning your usage on Pay As You Go will add up quickly:

You do get 5GB free when you transfer your old number onto Lebara. It’s a nice boost for joining them, but once you’ve got through that you might be better off on a network with cheaper tariffs.

One thing you might take issue with is that you have to make a “chargeable action” every 90 days or you’ll lose your credit. That could be a deal breaker if you want to get through your data in your own time.

You might be better off joining a 1-month SIM only deal on Lebara as they’re much better value for money. Or if you want to pay as you go on Vodafone’s network, we think ASDA are a better option (even without 5G).

7th: Three’s Pay As You Go rates are more expensive

Three PAYG

Traditional Pay As You Go at high ratesOrder a free SIM

at Three.co.uk
(opens in a new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Keep your SIM active by using it once every 180 days

What we don't like:
Red minus sign Their tariffs are very high

Three are the only main network to let you Pay As You Go in the traditional way. But that doesn’t really matter considering their high tariffs mean they won’t be an appealing choice for most users:

The cost of calls and data has gone up massively over time, and they have the highest tariff for calls out of all these networks. So they’re only really good if you use your phone very infrequently.

You can take a free SIM from their website here. While they only advertise their monthly bundles you can still pay as you go the traditional way. It’s worth checking Three’s signal coverage where you live.

To keep your SIM active you have to make at least one chargeable action (such as making a call or sending a text) every 180 days. So long as you do that your credit will never expire, unless you cancel your SIM.

Useful link: See all payg rates on Three

8th: Lycamobile have high Pay As You Go rates

Screenshot of Lycamobile's basic rates

Your usage will add up very quicklySee their rates

at lycamobile.co.uk
(opens in new window)

What we like:
Green plus sign Coverage via O2’s 5G/4G/3G/2G network
Green plus sign Hold onto your credit for up to a year

What we don't like:
Red minus sign Tariffs are very high
Red minus sign Data especially gets expensive fast
Red minus sign Your SIM will deactivate if you don’t use it every 90 days

Lycamobile are a smaller provider who use O2’s network. They’re the priciest network on this list for Pay As You Go rates. Paying per min, text and MB of data will quickly eat through your credit:

Data especially will add up very quickly (just 1GB would cost over £10!) when compared to the networks higher up the list. Their rates per min and text are also high, but not as high as some of the networks above.

Your credit lasts for a year on Lycamobile and you have to use your SIM every 90 days to hold onto it. It’s not like on ASDA where you can hold onto your credit forever, but it’s a good amount of time to use it up.

Infrequent users won’t like Lebara as you have to use your credit often to keep your SIM active. And frequent users will end up paying a lot with their high rates. So we can’t really see who would like this scheme.

Useful link: Lycamobile’s standard UK rates

O2 and Vodafone only offer Pay As You Go bundles these days

O2 logoVodafone logo

No traditional PAYG on these networks

O2 offered a great tariff 3p per min, 2p per text and 1p per MB way back in the past, only behind 1pMobile on cost. But the only way to “Pay As You Go” is with their “Big Bundles”, which include data rollover.

Vodafone offer bundles of mins, texts and data. They do have a PAYG scheme, but it costs you £1 per day to get unlimited mins, texts and 50MB of data. It’s not a very flexible option, but it’s there if you want it.

EE don’t offer traditional PAYG, opting for monthly bundles instead. And finally, Virgin Mobile and Sky Mobile don’t offer Pay As You Go schemes or monthly bundles, but each of them let you change plans each month.

So if you’re sure you want a traditional Pay As You Go scheme, then you’ll want to stay away from these networks.